Michael Jordan's Defensive Prowess and the 1988 DPOY Award: Reassessing NBA Legends

BASKETBALL / OPINION

As a child born in the 80s, my introduction to basketball was almost simultaneous with Michael Jordan's rise to superstardom. Growing up, Jordan was my idol, and anyone who knew teenage me could tell you I was obsessed with everything related to Jordan and the Chicago Bulls. However, despite my deep admiration for Jordan, I've come to believe that LeBron James is the greatest basketball player of all time. This belief isn't just about personal preference; it's rooted in an objective analysis of their careers, skills, and impacts on the game.

The Idolization of the 80s and 90s

There's a pervasive idea in basketball discussions that the game peaked around 1992 and that the greats of that era are unsurpassable. This notion suggests that the women of the 60s and 70s birthed the greatest basketball talent, which somehow hasn't been replicated since, maybe there was something in the water. This belief often overlooks the advancements in training, nutrition, and global talent scouting that have elevated the game to new heights today.

In the 80s and 90s, NBA players were revered not only for their on-court performance but also for their supposed impeccable conduct and sportsmanship. They are seen as untouchable, both in terms of their skills and their character. The offensive and defensive prowess of players from this era is often romanticized, creating an almost mythical status around them.

LeBron vs. Jordan: A Comparison

LeBron James embodies a combination of skill, size, athleticism, and an uncanny ability to stay healthy, driven by one of the greatest basketball minds in history. His career longevity and consistency are unmatched, and his ability to adapt and evolve his game over nearly two decades speaks volumes about his greatness.

However, the lack of objectivity when comparing eras is evident. The 80s and 90s players are often considered untouchable, and any current player is held to an almost impossible standard. For example, LeBron James was criticized for looking at the score sheet during a game, with accusations that he was trying to pad his stats. This incident was scrutinized heavily, unlike similar behaviors from past players.

Bob Rosenburg, a former NBA scorekeeper, once shared that Michael Jordan used to study the scorebook every time he reported to the table to re-enter the game. Jordan did this to ensure that newspaper stories began with "Michael Jordan..." This behavior, when attributed to Jordan, was seen as endearing and strategic, whereas LeBron faced criticism and accusations of selfishness for a similar act.

Media and Technology: Changing the Narrative

In Jordan's rookie season, many NBA games weren't even recorded or broadcasted. Only a limited number of games were shown nationally, allowing the NBA to control the narrative around its players. Today, every moment of NBA games is captured by thousands of cameras from countless angles, both officially and unofficially. This constant surveillance has changed how players are perceived and scrutinized.

Social media and advancements in technology have made it possible for anyone to broadcast a player's actions in real-time. This transparency has led to a more critical analysis of players' careers, both on and off the court. In Jordan's day, the NBA could present the image it wanted without much interference. Today, players' flaws are on full display, and the league cannot control the narrative as it once did.

Michael Jordan's Defensive Prowess: Fact or Fiction?

A recent article on Yahoo Sports raised significant questions about the validity of Michael Jordan's 1988 Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) award. The piece suggested that Jordan's defensive stats might have been inflated, thereby casting doubt on his reputation as an all-time great defender. While Jordan was undeniably a very good defender, the claim that he was consistently the best or second-best defender at his position for several years, as implied by his multiple consecutive First Team All-Defensive selections, deserves closer scrutiny.

The 1988 DPOY Award and Its Controversy

Michael Jordan won the Defensive Player of the Year award in 1988, a season in which he also claimed the MVP award. This dual accolade marked him as one of only four players in NBA history to win both awards in the same season. His 1987-88 season was statistically impressive; Jordan led the league in steals and was a dominant force on both ends of the floor. However, a closer examination of the era and the practices of scorekeeping brings some of these achievements into question.

According to the Yahoo Sports article, there are concerns about the accuracy of Jordan's defensive statistics during his DPOY season. It points out that home team scorekeepers, including those in Chicago, had a tendency to inflate the stats of their star players. This practice means that Jordan's reported defensive metrics may not fully reflect his actual performance on the court. The inflation of stats wasn't exclusive to Jordan or the Bulls; it was a broader issue within the league, affecting the perceived performances of many players from that era.

Scorekeeping Bias and Its Implications

Former NBA scorekeeper Alex Rucker has highlighted the bias that existed in the scorekeeping process. Home team scorekeepers often recorded inflated statistics for their players, which could make them appear more dominant than they actually were. This bias could significantly impact how players' careers and contributions are viewed historically. If Jordan's stats were indeed inflated, it raises questions about the legitimacy of his numerous All-Defensive First Team selections and his 1988 DPOY award.

This potential inflation of stats is not to suggest that Jordan was not an elite defender. His ability to read the game, his quick hands, and his competitive nature made him a formidable opponent. However, the idea that he was the absolute best defender at his position for several consecutive years might be more myth than fact. It's important to consider that while Jordan's defensive skills were top-tier, the narrative around his defensive prowess may have been bolstered by these inflated statistics.

Comparative Analysis: Jordan vs. Contemporary Defenders

When comparing Jordan to his contemporaries, it's essential to look at other defensive standouts of his time, such as Hakeem Olajuwon and Gary Payton. Olajuwon, who won the DPOY award twice, was known for his shot-blocking and overall defensive impact, particularly in the paint. Payton, who won the DPOY award in 1996, was renowned for his perimeter defense and was one of the few guards to win the award post-Jordan's era.

The narrative that Jordan was the best defender during his peak is somewhat challenged when considering these players' contributions. Olajuwon and Payton's defensive capabilities were also elite, and their achievements in this area highlight that the competition for the title of the best defender was fierce and not solely owned by Jordan.

Scottie Pippen's Perspective

Scottie Pippen, Jordan's teammate and one of the greatest wing defenders in NBA history, has been vocal about his frustrations regarding the Defensive Player of the Year award. Pippen never won the award during his career, despite being a 10-time All-Defensive team member. Pippen has suggested that the media's focus on Jordan may have cost him the DPOY award.

"I think they were too busy watching Michael," Pippen said during an interview. His comments highlight the intense media focus on Jordan, which may have overshadowed other deserving players' contributions. Pippen's bitterness about never winning DPOY reflects a broader issue of how media narratives can shape perceptions of player greatness. Pippen also eluded to and confirmed the scorekeeping bias back in 2021 “Say I deflected the ball and tapped it over to [MJ]. I should get the credit with the steal right? Nope," Pippen wrote. "More often that not, the steal went into his column in the stat sheet and I could do nothing about it… One night a scorekeeper came into the locker room… to hand the stat sheets to Phil Jackson… I couldn’t believe the look the guy gave Michael: ‘See MJ, we take care of you.”

Revisiting Jordan's Defensive Legacy

While Michael Jordan's defensive legacy is substantial, it's worth reassessing with a critical eye. His accolades and recognitions are numerous, but they exist within a context that allowed for potential inflation and bias. This doesn't diminish Jordan's greatness but adds a layer of complexity to how we understand and compare players across different eras.

Jordan was a defensive powerhouse, but like all players, he was also a beneficiary of the era's specific conditions and practices. Acknowledging this doesn't take away from his achievements but rather provides a more nuanced understanding of his legacy and the evolution of the game.

In conclusion, the reassessment of Michael Jordan's defensive prowess highlights the need for a more nuanced approach to evaluating historical players. As we continue this series, we will delve deeper into other aspects of NBA history, separating fact from fiction and offering a more comprehensive view of the legends of the game.

Stay tuned to Blerdz.net for more updates on NBA history and other sports news. Follow us on our social media channels: Twitter, YouTube, Instagram, and Facebook. 👓